Doctrine
BG3 β / −β Rational Humanitarian ⇔ Pragmatic

Doctrine

Doctrine ── DOCTRINE
A group where the humanitarian intellect that raises ideals and guides people connects with the pragmatic force that orders matters by discipline.

The character of this group

The Doctrine Block Group brings together a duality pair from β and a duality pair from −β — four types sharing the L5 upper-function attributes Humanitarian / Pragmatic club and Linear-Assertive / Balanced-Stable. Inside the group, the metabolic cycle Ideal ⇄ Discipline turns continuously.

Two opposing value-worlds (β and −β) cohabit, but the quadra dichotomies (陽気⇔深刻・賢明⇔果敢・民主⇔貴族) cancel out — what remains is the mixed character of "The Mentor raises the ideal and ignites (generation) → the Executive drops it into stages and implements it (storage) → the Philosopher weighs its meaning and returns it to information (information generation) → the Inspector sets it as discipline and returns it to the next (information accumulation). This is Doctrine’s cycle." Read in one breath: each of the four types takes a position in the cycle and spins this single round of labor.

Two value-worlds inside the group

The group simultaneously holds β and −β. The three quadra dichotomies are exact opposites and cancel inside the group, so neither quadra color survives — only the shared club and temperament ground remain.

β quadra
Merry · Bold · Aristocratic
Burns for an ideal, moves people and erects order. Mentor EIE-Q · Inspector LSI-D.
−β quadra
Serious · Wise · Democratic
Weighs the meaning of ideals; supports discipline by ethics. Philosopher EII-Q · Executive LSE-D.
陽気⇔深刻・賢明⇔果敢・民主⇔貴族 — all three dichotomies cancel, so no quadra color remains in Doctrine's character. What remains is the shared Humanitarian/Pragmatic club ground and the L5 upper functions linked upon it.

Three shared traits — the linkage axes

What remains after neutralization is the three attributes the L5 upper function carries: club, temperament and questim/declatim. These connect same-attribute pairs and shape the group's character.

Linked by club
Humanitarian: Ideal & agitation + Ethics & meaning
Pragmatic: Pragmatics & ordering + Discipline & execution
Humanitarian pole raising ideals, pragmatic pole ordering by discipline.
Linked by temperament
Linear-Assertive: Ideal & agitation + Pragmatics & ordering
Balanced-Stable: Ethics & meaning + Discipline & execution
Tempo that pushes outward, and tempo that sets deeply.
Linked by Q/D
Questim: the two humanitarian functions
Declatim: the two pragmatic functions
Questioning meaning and setting discipline (co-varies with club).

In Doctrine, "Humanitarian = Questim" and "Pragmatic = Declatim" coincide. Meaning is questioned from the humanitarian side; discipline is set from the pragmatic side — the form of grounding ideals in practice.

Members — four types and their roles

The four types of Doctrine take positions of Leader, Implementer, Proofreader and Stabilizer in the metabolic cycle.

L5 upper functions of the four types

Type Value block L5 upper function Club Temperament Q/D
Mentor EIE-Q +Fe-p × −Ni-c Fe-Ni-Qi "Ideal & agitation" Humanitarian Linear Questim
Executive LSE-D −Te-p × +Si-c Te-Si-Di "Pragmatics & ordering" Pragmatic Linear Declatim
Philosopher EII-Q −Fi-p × +Ne-c Fi-Ne-Qe "Ethics & meaning" Humanitarian Balanced Questim
Inspector LSI-D +Ti-p × −Se-c Ti-Se-De "Discipline & execution" Pragmatic Balanced Declatim

Metabolic cycle

Leader Mentor Energy generation Implementer Executive Energy storage Proofreader Philosopher Information generation Stabilizer Inspector Information accumulation Ideal ⇄ Discipline cycle
Energy system (generation, storage) Information system (generation, accumulation)

The Mentor raises the ideal and ignites (generation) → the Executive drops it into stages and implements it (storage) → the Philosopher weighs its meaning and returns it to information (information generation) → the Inspector sets it as discipline and returns it to the next (information accumulation). This is Doctrine’s cycle.

Within-group compatibility map

Placing the four types at the corners of a square gives a clean compatibility map. The diagonals are duality (matched values, comfort 100); the top and bottom edges are role (same temperament, masked ego); the left and right edges are distance (same club, opposite values). Each face links to its type page; each relation label links to its detail page.

RoleDualityRoleDualityDistanceDistanceEIE-QLeaderLSE-DExecutive ManagerEII-QPhilosopherLSI-DExecutive

The six inner relations in detail

Duality ×2DUALITY · comfort 100
Same quadra指導者EIE-Q ↔ 執行官LSI-D/哲学者EII-Q ↔ 実務官LSE-D。価値が一致し完全補完。
Distance ×2DISTANCE · comfort 0
Same club指導者EIE-Q ↔ 哲学者EII-Q(人道)/実務官LSE-D ↔ 執行官LSI-D(実務)。同じ話題、価値は逆向き。
Role ×2ROLE · comfort 0
Same temperament指導者EIE-Q ↔ 実務官LSE-D(直線主張)/哲学者EII-Q ↔ 執行官LSI-D(バランス安定)。同じテンポで動けるが、自我を仮面で覆う。

The "opposite values" tension carried by distance and role underpins the group-level neutralization. The presence of dualizing third parties softens that tension.

Where Doctrine appears

理念を掲げる人道と規律で整える実務が連結するため、信条は「理念を掲げ、意味を問い、規律として据える場」で力を発揮します。指導者が方向を示し、実務官が段取り、哲学者が意味を吟味し、執行官が規律に据える ── 理念が制度として根づきます。

一方で暗示が群内の双対で満たされ無意識が眠るため、信条もまた外へ開かず、同じ理念が回り続ける自己充足の停滞(膠着)に陥りやすい影を持ちます。